こちらもいかがですか

買い物かご

VIP 特典をお楽しみいただけます!

楽天Kobo VIP会員になると、対象商品が10%引きで購入できるほか、Koboスーパーポイントも2倍獲得できます。

購入できない書籍
お買い物かごをご確認ください。購入不可の商品を削除できます。削除されなかった購入不可の商品は、購入手続き時に削除されます。
評価とレビュー(15 109 星評価
15 レビュー

総合評価

4.55
109
5 つ星 4 つ星 3 つ星 2 つ星 1 つ星
69 32 4 3 1

感想を共有

この本のレビューはすでに投稿いただいております。

投稿いただきましたレビューは現在審査中です。

レビューの完成

すべてのレビュー

  • 1 人がこのレビューが参考になったと回答

    1 人がこのレビューが参考になったと回答

    11 人がこのレビューが参考になったと回答

    ご意見ありがとうございます!

    Before We Were Yours

    Excellent! Wonderful, powerful story!Hard to put this book down.
  • 1 人がこのレビューが参考になったと回答

    1 人がこのレビューが参考になったと回答

    11 人がこのレビューが参考になったと回答

    ご意見ありがとうございます!

    Worth a read

    Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an advance copy of this book in return for an honest review. Before We Were Yours is based on the true story of Georgia Tann and the Tennessee Children’s Home Society. This abhorent piece of history fascinates me. While it operated, primarily as a means for wealthy childless couples to buy children, it was a well-kept secret. It went on for decades*, which is amazing considering the thousands of children stolen from their parents, as well as the estimated hundreds of children that died in the home. The depth and breadth of the cover-up is unimaginable. As for this book, it does a fair job at telling the story. It is based on the Foss family’s children, who are stolen in the night from their shanty boat. Years later, the sisters are reunited, but decide to keep their story secret. Many years later, a granddaughter, Avery, follows up some strange coincidences, leading her to their past. I would have liked to see a bit more of a fore- or afterword on Georgia Tann and the Home. The story is told from the past viewpoint of Rill Foss and the present viewpoint of Avery. Avery is one of those characters you just don’t connect with. She is engaged to be married, but you know she is going to break it off because of her new love interest, which just doesn’t read true. The author keeps reminding you Avery is a high-powered attorney, yet she can’t make a decision or read the clues in front of her. On the other hand, the stories centering on Rill Foss, were captivating. At 12 years old, Rill is trying to keep her family together after being kidnapped and molested. Her viewpoint is a story of family, love and sacrifice, and Avery just appeared to be self-centered. Avery was such a contrast to Rill, that reading the viewpoints alternately just didn’t work. *It appears Georgia Tann had been a well-respected social worker beginning in the 1920’s, and my cursory research couldn’t find when she “turned.”
  • 1 人がこのレビューが参考になったと回答

    1 人がこのレビューが参考になったと回答

    11 人がこのレビューが参考になったと回答

    ご意見ありがとうございます!

    Before We Were Your

    Absolutely great! The characters are so real! I’m sad for the book to end.
  • 0 人がこのレビューが参考になったと回答

    0 人がこのレビューが参考になったと回答

    00 人がこのレビューが参考になったと回答

    ご意見ありがとうございます!

    Fabulous story

    Fabulous read what a sad and haunting story. What the children that this story is based on went through is horrible to think about.
  • 1 人がこのレビューが参考になったと回答

    1 人がこのレビューが参考になったと回答

    12 人がこのレビューが参考になったと回答

    ご意見ありがとうございます!

    Beautiful Yet Shocking Story!

    I was excited to be picked to be apart of Lisa Wingate's Sisterhood of the Traveling Book 2017. I have done this on several occasions and it is a lot of fun. This time the book that we are reading and sharing between "Sisters" is her new book "Before We Were Yours." I am not sure how to write a review on this book. I know I love books that bounce from modern day settings to a historical setting and back to modern day. I know I'm still in a state of shock over a part of twentieth century history I knew nothing about, Memphis Tennessee Children's Home Society orphanage and its awful director Georgia Tann. There will always be cruelty in the world. History is full of it. Lisa did a great job sharing with us a part that you and I and many others have heard nothing about. I know there are tears on the edge of my eyes. I know I want to weep for the truths that are a part of this fictional story that is so beautifully told by Lisa Wingate. I know it's a departure from some of Lisa's other styles of books. It isn't my favorite book of Lisa's but I sure do love her stories. May this history never repeat itself!
109

この書籍は以下のデバイスでお読みいただけます。

  • デスクトップ
  • 電子書籍リーダー
  • IOS
  • ANDROID
  • タブレット
  • WINDOWS